hi, i was hoping someone could shine a light on an issue me and my fiancee are facing.
We would love to have a church wedding, and we have been to see a few churches. We recently paid a deposit on one which we loved and that was in the same area where her parents live, and was accepted by the reverend as my fiancee used to live in the same area for a number of years .
Me and my family are raised catholics but i will be honest in saying I'm not very religious any more as a 'practising Catholic' but my parents and grandparents are. My fiancee classes herself as an atheist or a 'nothing' as she calls it. As her parents are not very religious and did not raise her to follow a certain religion.
The big issue is that the church we have booked is a Protestant church. This was something which passed by me and i have no answer for why i did not ask. The reverend didn't ask us what religion we were either and said a marriage ceremony there would be fine.
Im just really concerned now if this is a major issue. Is it frowned upon? i really don't want to upset my parents or grandparents. Also will this have any further implications, I've seen on some websites that the marriage would be void. Also would it affect us if we decide to have children in the future as to what religion we raise them to follow.
My fiancee is under the impression that it will be fine as her parents were married in a protestant church and they were both non practicing catholics.
Could anybody help me with this, wether you have any past experiance similar to this, or any advise to offer.
We are not getting married until april 2014 so we have time to ammend this if its more serious than we thought.
Thanks for your help
EDIT - THE CATEGORY HAS BEEN CHANGED FOR THIS THREAD .... IF YOU ARE NOT SURE WHERE TO POST IT PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CONTACT ONE OF THE MODS AND WE WILL SORT IT FOR YOU
CommentAuthorPoppy x
edited
Why not have a word with them to see how they'd react? It's not like you deliberately went out of your way to do it, it just seemed a lovely venue. Another poster a while back had the same issue, but found that they appeased family by getting a Catholic priest to do a blessing there. If it is the venue of your dreams, there will be ways around it. I'll see if I can find the thread it was mentioned in x
(By the way, this thread may well get moved as it's posted in the wrong place - mods only here)
CommentAuthorMrsA-J
Your best asking your family...
and maybe going to the church and checking its ok! Telling him you didnt realise/know but youd still love to get married there... he might have to pull some strings... it really depends on the vicar. One church we went to was very strict and said hed have to christen me and id have to go to church and me accepted into the church group and when all that had happened hed marry us-luckily i didnt want that church anyway.
xx
CommentAuthorPoppy x
edited
There is another thread - titled 'Furious and heartbroken'. Hope you find a compromise.
CommentAuthorLittle Kettle
As far as I know, it's not illegal to get married in a church if you are not of that religion. Some people may think it is disrespectful, but I'm pretty sure there are no legal implications in it.
Ok so the whole marriage being void thing isn't legal wise, in the eyes of the law you would be married, but the Catholic church will not acknowledge your marriage unless you marry in a Catholic church, which could cause implications at a later date if you want to christen your children Catholic. Other than that, there isn't anything really stopping you from having whichever church you chose xxx
Got together 14.02.2008
Got engaged 31.12.2010
Will become a Mrs on 30.08.2014 xxxxxx
CommentAuthorInDreamland
I'm Catholic and getting married in a Catholic church (H2B is Methodist but not practising).
For me (and other Catholics) it is important to get married in a Catholic church to be married in God's eyes. We'd be considered married by the Church as well as legally. We usually get married in our local Parish church unless there is a reason/connection to another Church in a different Parish (normally a family history connection, not just because we think one looks "prettier" than another as is sometimes the case).
If you and your OH choose to marry in a different denomination church and the priest/vicar/reverend is happy to marry you, the marriage will not be void (legally) and in the eyes of that denomination you will be married too. So you really don't need to worry about that. Just ensure either your BANNS are read or you give notice at your local registry office and there is a registrar at the ceremony for the legal bit.
The complications may come at a later date if you decide you want any of your children baptised in the Catholic church. It doesn't sound like either of you would be interested in that at the moment but you never know if the future you may change your mind, it's incredible how people change their minds as they get older ;)
I think your biggest challenge may be your family if they do not approve of a non-RC but only you will know them well enough to know how they will react. At the end of the day though, parents/grandparents should respect your choice to marry wherever you choose.
Good luck and don't worry x
Married the love of my life on Saturday 11th May 2013 xxx
Had our dream perfect honeymoon in Hawaii!
CommentAuthormillz090
Finally marrying the love of my life !!
10th August 2013 - 9 years to the day we met !
CommentAuthormadhen
Cracking post InDreamland, says it all :)
CommentAuthorAntonyJ
Thank you so much for all your replies! You have really helped settle our minds! Ive also had a chat with my parents and as InDreamland said they would respect our choice. We'll face the whole 'children being baptised' scenario when we get there, a few years yet!!! Thanks again!!!! Antony
CommentAuthorLinzi-jo
Glad you've worked it all out now :) xx
Got together 14.02.2008
Got engaged 31.12.2010
Will become a Mrs on 30.08.2014 xxxxxx
CommentAuthorInDreamland
Nice to hear you managed to sort this one out and you can hopefully now go forth and enjoy the planning process xx
Married the love of my life on Saturday 11th May 2013 xxx
Had our dream perfect honeymoon in Hawaii!
CommentAuthorMrs Ross
@indreamland just wonsering why would he need a registar there at the church? wouldnt the vicar marry him? im only asking as im getting married in a church too
CommentAuthorLinzi-jo
You only need a registrar there if you are marrying in a denomination that is not CofE to make it legal by law MrsRoss2b xxx
Got together 14.02.2008
Got engaged 31.12.2010
Will become a Mrs on 30.08.2014 xxxxxx
CommentAuthor*KelBel*
I was just wondering also, what does it matter between marrying there and then subsequent christenings? If they hadn't married and had children, what happens with the christenings then? I didn't think it would matter either way...?
Velcro...my wedding day twinny! The Two Kel's!
Got engaged 14/10/12 in Central Park NYC!
Became Mrs Macdonald 13th September 2014
Mummy to 4 girlies and baby blue boy Due 10/05/2016
CommentAuthorLinzi-jo
It's frowned upon to have children out of wedlock so some Catholic churches will not christen them, and if you are not married in a Catholic church they dont see you as being married (even if legally you are) so it can cause problems with certain vicars xxx
Got together 14.02.2008
Got engaged 31.12.2010
Will become a Mrs on 30.08.2014 xxxxxx
CommentAuthorInDreamland
Sorry Ladies, just got back on the site. Thanks for answering for me LinziJo :D - good answers xx
Married the love of my life on Saturday 11th May 2013 xxx
Had our dream perfect honeymoon in Hawaii!