Basically, I'm fed up of waiting for him to propose so I'm thinking of dealing with it myself. He has always said its £ stopping him so I'm thinking of pricing up and saving up myself. The date I have in mind is October 2016 so plenty of time (hopefully!). I have this silly idea in my head that if he hasn't already proposed then I can ask him on Valentines Day 2016 as it's a Leap Year, and then say "oh by the way, the wedding's this year!"
Is this a horrible idea?? I seriously doubt he would freak and leave me (we already live together and have 3 kids, will have been together 8 years this October).
I would be grateful for any feedback.
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
To be honest hun, it sounds like a great plan and all that but I don't think you should spring on him that the wedding is that year, especially as by that point it'll be in 8 months time. I just think you should at least get an answer first and give it time to settle in and that before talking through plans. It's tougher than it looks to plan a wedding, especially by yourself and you may find it much harder to keep it secret than you plan it to be xxx
CommentAuthorsarah
I love the idea of you proposing, but a surprise wedding for the groom not so much. I'm not sure you could keep the planning secret and I think it might be a lot of unnecessary tension when he does find out. I say propose and then plan from there.
CommentAuthorElinor Claire
You don't have to wait until a leap year to propose, and anyway it's not Valentines you would do it on, but February 29th. Perhaps if you save up quietly for a year, see what you can get together, and if he still hasn't proposed, then you can say "I've got a wedding fund started and this is what is in it so far, imagine what we can yet in another year or two". Then he might think of proposing.
30th August 2014 was the best birthday ever.
It was the day that I became Mrs. Dixon.
CommentAuthorRachaelC80
I agree with Elinor Claire!!! It's a lovely idea to propose but a surprise Wedding, not so sure???
I think it's one thing saving up the money ready, but I would hold off arranging things
1. As he might have his own idea of what he wants/doesn't want and would like to get involved...Im not sure if you're actually talking about booking things before the proposal, but I'm sure he would like to have his input. 2. He might feel pressurised into agreeing if things are already booked etc. 3. Planning a wedding is something that is nice to do together and personally, I think it has bought myself and h2b closer. 4. Practically, can you keep it under wraps? Our venue and a lot of suppliers require both the bride and grooms signature on contracts..also, there are things to consider regarding his family etc.
That said, I think it's a lovely idea to propose to him.
Maybe you could have a chat and explain to him that you appreciate tha you can't get married straight away, but it would be nice to get engaged so you can start the ball rolling? There are plenty of brides on here planning 2016 and beyond weddings, it really isn't at all unusual to have a longer engagement nowadays xx
My Beating Heart Belongs To You
30 August 2013
The First Day Of My Happily Ever After
CommentAuthorElizabethP8
I agree with Elinor and Laura, you can propose any time you want :) I'd start the saving so when you do decide to go for it you can show him that money isn't a concern as you have managed to save X amount without any trouble. He may feel a bit cornered if you give him 8 months notice and stuff is already book, also keeping secrets is easier said than done! xx
CommentAuthorFinally Susan B
I think only you know your partner and your relationship well enough to decide if a surprise wedding would be a disaster or a blessing for him. In general I would say against a surprise - Laura Jo makes good points as to why. Apart from his emotions ..also to add with 3 children, I'm sure you will want them involved and they are usually useless at keeping secrets (dress fittings etc). Making anything yourself - my spare room is overtaken with storing wedding things.
If you're fed up waiting for him to propose, start dropping huge hints? Or just general chat how being married is starting to feel important to you etc x
CommentAuthorLauraM9144
i think to answer that quetion i would put myself in his shoes . If my h2b did it to me i think i would understand why he did but i would be so dissappointed in having no input or even just the build up of excitement etc. My other half is not always th emost helpful when asking wedding related questions but it just wouldnt be the same if he knew nothing!! again we have 3 children and its all part of the day that they get to be art of the planning and the excitement which yours wouldnt as if you told them they would surely let it slip :/ as someone said before if you want to save money then you wll need to make alot of things by hand how will you hide that? i know the reasoning is lovely but i think maybe a special proposal and maybe some research so you can share with him how cost effective you can make it? then have fun planning it together! maybe he doesnt think you would be up for a long engagement and therefore the only reason he hasnt proposed is because he thinks he would have to come up with a wedding within a short amount of time?
One BIG day will lead to lots of little happy days !!
I think a surprise proposal is lovely. however as some of the ladies have said, planning a surprise wedding yourself may put added stress on you and will take away his option to have an opinion or get excited. X
CommentAuthorShazk
Im witht he other ladies Im not sure planning on the wedding before even proposing is good idea x
I like idea of starting the saving to show him what can be done etc and you proposing to him but im not sure on the rest xxx
Away with the flutterbys xxx
CommentAuthorlinz2015
I think it depends on the man you have. my h2b would be very happy to have a surprise wedding as he isn't bothered by any of the detail and planning just the vows and so 8 months notice would be fine for him. However yur man might be different, given the chance he might want to be quite involved inthe planning and build up and feel he has missed out if not given the chance. You know him best. May be you should just propose and go from there.
CommentAuthorlala "mod" bunni
one thing i think you need to consider is that maybe proposing and saying the wedding is ........ may make him feel he is backed to a corner , i know if i had done that to Mr Lala he would have turned and walked
My h2b proposed on my 20th birthday (im now 25), however just over a year ago he broke the engagement off due to stress and everything that was going on. well things got better between us and i had been wearing his engagement ring due to it meaning something to me even if it meant nothing to him.... i fell and the ring flew off my finger and snapped clean in half, a mutual friend (mainly h2b's friend) put an idea in my head, he said "do you nt think it broke because it was on the wrong person?" well see this comment made me think, i went out, replaced the ring, cooked a 3course meal & proposed to him this valentines, well he said yes.
We already had my dress & our rings had already been made and paid and delivered. I had already made the invites.
I suggested putting away £30 per month (him alone) stating i too will put money away. Well so far i have planned most of the wedding, the finances are still being gathered but we now have BM's outfits, guestbooks & pen/holder, centre pieces, flowers, OOS's, favours etc. the only things left are ceremony room, reception room, food, cake, his suit, our kids suits, & college photographer. He has not put any money away yet! & I have only been saving since end of feb!
I have not mentioned to h2b about his lack of saving for the wedding as as far as im concerned it will be his fault if we dont have a honeymoon the same year as our wedding! lol I know that come the wedding day i will have paid for the entire wedding and am only asking him to save £1000 in the next 2years. which SHOULD be simple!
Personally I would propose to him on any day! Leap year is nothing special, the idea of women proposing on leap year was back when its the mans "duty" to do all of that, however, times have changed, more is expected of women these days, if we have to go out and work like men, we are expected to put bread on the table as they do, then why the h3ll cant we propose when we want to?!
Propose to him, then start saving, ask him what he feels he could put away each month, work out what you can put away each month, then sort your date out. At the end of the day a date is not important. If you start saving then realise that your car blows up and you need a new one pretty pronto in order to get to work, but you have your heart set on a particular date..... what are you going to do? forego the date to use your savings to buy a car to get to work each day? or get sacked because you cant get to work due to no car and end up having to forego your date anyway because you have no job to fund the wedding?
I have recently done something similar (yesterday in fact!) I wanted a garden funiture set, spent £85, logged into online banking this morning and realised that i cant pay the bills cos i spent too much money yesterday! so my wedding savings will be paying for that now, which means for the next few months i will have to put away slightly more than expected to cover the loss i made yesterday!