My brothers girlfiend is pregnant and due to give birth middle of this year.
We have our wedding planned for next year and ive said to my parents i dont want any babys at the wedding ceremony. its only going to be a small intermate venue and i dont want a baby crying all the way through it. we have spent alot of time writing our own vows and planning every detail, which i would like people to hear etc. also to probably sound totally selfish i want the day to be about me and h2b not the baby which i know will happen (ive had people say dont worry its your day but i know how things will go and it will be more about the baby than us)
mum is utterly disgusted that i dont want baby there but tbh if its was other way round i wouldnt bring a small child i knew may cry etc, i also havent mentioned this to my brother yet as im not sure how to approach it etc.
any view advice welcome :/ even if its that im being too selfish.....
Is a very lucky girl :)
CommentAuthor*KelBel*
I'm only having my children at the wedding who will be 8,5 and almost 4... I'm not having any other children,not even my niece,they can like it or lump it, this will apply if h2b's sisters get pregnant and have a baby before the wedding, I'm not being funny but surely your brothers girlfriends parents (who will be the other set of grandparents) could look after the baby for that one day?x
Velcro...my wedding day twinny! The Two Kel's!
Got engaged 14/10/12 in Central Park NYC!
Became Mrs Macdonald 13th September 2014
Mummy to 4 girlies and baby blue boy Due 10/05/2016
CommentAuthorhis duck
yes i know her mum and or sister could have the baby.
Is a very lucky girl :)
CommentAuthor*KelBel*
I think u should suggest that option, I think mums are the worst when it comes to kids and babies at weddings, but it's your day, so u should have the choice on guests you want!
Velcro...my wedding day twinny! The Two Kel's!
Got engaged 14/10/12 in Central Park NYC!
Became Mrs Macdonald 13th September 2014
Mummy to 4 girlies and baby blue boy Due 10/05/2016
CommentAuthorMrs van der Lee
I'm having no children [except the odd one or two] at ours!
Ive had the exact same problem. There was no babies invited at all, or children for that matter. Then one of my friends announces she is pregnant! and is bringing the baby (who will be one by then) to the wedding... so im like noooooo i didnt want kids. But when I told people they said i was being bridezilla and cannot put a pregnancy ban on my guests! lol. which is obviously true.
I thought about it and if one of my bridesmaids had a baby now, I wouldnt dream of telling them the baby wasnt coming. So i cant do it for other guests. Also, everyone is at a different stage in their life and cant all hold on to have a baby, to fit in with your plans. (ive had this talk from my mum, so just para phrasing!!)
I know exactly how you feel, and we have done exactly the same with the initmate wedding, our own vows and readings etc. But I hope that if a baby cries during any of it, the mum should have the initiative and courtesy to take the baby away quickly and settle it, so as not to interupt. Have a word with her before if you think it will be a problem. Im guessing when your saying your vows, nobody else in the world will matter. And just remember, if it was your baby, you might be offended if your brother didnt invite his first neice/nephew and it could cause family friction that you dont need!
Good luck! xx
CommentAuthor*KelBel*
I think the only way I'd have an exception was if the baby was not very old and only if the mum was breast feeding x
Velcro...my wedding day twinny! The Two Kel's!
Got engaged 14/10/12 in Central Park NYC!
Became Mrs Macdonald 13th September 2014
Mummy to 4 girlies and baby blue boy Due 10/05/2016
CommentAuthorSianyCaitlin
We're only having 3 children, my sister who is a BM & will be 9, my goddaughter who is a FG & will be 1 & a half & h2b's neice/goddaughter who is also a FG & will be 2 & a half. We've told everybody else that we do not wish to have children there & they've understood & are grateful for a night off! xx
Got together 06/07/2009
Got engaged 16/07/2012
I marry my best friend 08/06/2014
Can't wait to be Mrs Sharp x
CommentAuthorhis duck
i wouldnt take my baby if it was that young. and wouldb be offended. Unfortunately the place we are having the wedding isnt sneak out-able. i have thougt about it long and hard but just dont want babies there. reception im not bothered about. even my best friend/maid of honour isnt bringing her kids for this reason and ive not even asked her about it she just didnt think it woyld be fair.
Is a very lucky girl :)
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
I can see where you're coming from, but personally I don't see the problem with having babies at a wedding. I've been married before and can speak from experience that my sister had a baby that was one month old by the time that wedding came and i didn't notice any crying on the day, when the baby started to cry, my sister's husband just took her out the room, so maybe your brother's girlfriend could just do that? I just think that if it was me, I'd be worrying most of the day about my baby and if they were okay and if the person looking after them were coping alright. I think really it's nice to have babies at a wedding, so can't say anything that will really help you on this subject. xxx
CommentAuthorJoanna
The baby won't necessarily cry and even if it does, surely the mum would take the baby outside to calm her down and not disrupt the vows? Also, this baby will be your niece or nephew. Surely you'll be close to the baby and want him/her to be there for your day?
The greatest thing you'll ever learn
is just to love and be loved in return
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
Yeah, agree with Joanna there hun xxx You could have some nice pictures taken with the baby xxx
CommentAuthorBuggerlugs
My son was only 3 weeks old when I attended my dads wedding he was fantastic he didnt cry at all but if he did we were prepared, we sat on the end we made sure we were near a door had all the necessary things at the ready dummy, bottle etc and all the focus wasnt on the baby it was on my dad and his new wife yes people came and had a look at him after all he was only 3 weeks old so hadnt been out much so for alot of the family it was the first time meeting him ... Im sure if a baby was to come to my wedding the parents of that child would be as prepared as us as they wont want to spoil your wedding .. there are 7 children so far coming to my wedding and i know my bridesmaid wants children soon but she is planning it around moving house and my wedding bless her so if she is not pregnant at the wedding she will have her baby there
CommentAuthormillz090
It is your choice and if you really dont want them there then say no however be prepared for some backlash i think. how old will the baby be at your wedding? What if she is breast feeding? wont really be able to leave the baby for too long so be prepared for them to leave early potentially. This will be your niece/nephew so dont you want them in the family pictures? they will be part of your family?
We are not inviting friends children, only families children as my family too and most people dont mind but i know if i told my brother he couldnt bring my niece/nephew especially as a baby he would be quite hurt and upset with me. However we have a few babies coming and i know their mothers would take the children out if they are crying out of respect for the wedding going ahead. xxx
Finally marrying the love of my life !!
10th August 2013 - 9 years to the day we met !
CommentAuthorSianyCaitlin
If you really don't want children there, don't have them, it's your choice. I think a lot of people will be grateful to be able to let their hair down & have a drink etc. If I had children, I wouldn't take them to a wedding as if they did cry during the ceremony, I wouldn't want to miss any of it by taking them out. But everybody has different opinions, so do what you want :) xx
Got together 06/07/2009
Got engaged 16/07/2012
I marry my best friend 08/06/2014
Can't wait to be Mrs Sharp x
CommentAuthorMrsLJDeaton
By the time my wedding finally gets here there will be 2 2yr olds so thinking of making little goodie bags to keep them busy or let them have lil sweets or choccies to hopefully keep them quiet during the service One will be our lil mini me and his or her cousin as sil wants to have a child Sept 2014 and as there ares and family Nannies will have to keep them quiet and busy so good luck to nannies as terrible 2s. =D X
Started going out 23.10.2010 met at Barnet college
Engaged 23.08.2012 In Turkey Our 1st Holiday Together
To be Mrs Lana Jocelyn Deaton on 23.10.2015 5 years the day
Jamiroquai Arthur Gordon Deaton Born 29/05/2015 My Son Jammy
CommentAuthorMrsWright290912
We only had our nephew to our daytime of the wedding. He was 13 months old at the time. When he got grisly his Dad (SILs Hubby) just took him out of the room. People did fuss over the baby but to be honest, we barely noticed it at all as so many were fussing over us.
I can see your mums POV - You can hardly expect them to find someone to have the baby and attend or in fact not attend at all. There is often a rule and an exception, like with us at our wedding and having our nephew. I do think to be honest you should have a rethink and have your niece/nephew there. We had some lovely photos of me holding my newphew and in our family photos too.
I really did marry my Mr Wright and we had a nice day for a
Wright wedding!
Mexico for our first anniversary
CommentAuthorJenniferY90
My h2b was adament that he didn't want any children at the wedding, until I pointed out that this meant that none of his 5 nieces or nephews could come to the wedding, so now we are allowing children, a few people who will still have small children have already said that they won't be bringing them, as for the others, there is an area in the church with loads of toys and the parents will all be reminded before hand that if their children start playing up then they are to take them out immediately! I know a lot of people who have stated that there will be no children at their wedding, we compromised and said that children must all be gone by 7pm so the adults can have a drink and a dance without worrying about any children being around their feet. The people who said complete No to their weddings didn't seem to have too many issues, people need to remember that it is your day, if you don't want children there then you shouldn't be forced to have them there.
CommentAuthorbarbie86
We're not having any children at the wedding; if people can't come, so be it, but we're not making any exceptions as we are extremely limited on space, we don't like children, and we aren't close to any children. So, I totally get where you're coming from, and personally, I wouldn't relax my stance on the issue.
However, if you do decide that you won't make any exceptions, you do need to be understanding if your brother's girlfriend decides not to attend, as that is her choice, and if the baby is small and breastfeeding, she may simple not be able to come. Only you can know if you'd be OK with that; similarly, only you can know if this might cause bad feeling with her family and with your brother. If you feel it might, and want to avoid that, perhaps you could consider allowing the baby to be at the wedding breakfast, but request that your brother's girlfriend stays outside the ceremony room during the ceremony, if your main concern is your vows being ruined; maybe that might be a compromise.
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
To be honest, i don't think you can say to someone that they can come to the wedding with their baby, and then ask them to stay outside the ceremony room for the entire service, what would be the point in her being there in that case? I'm sure if the baby starts to cry, she'll go outside to calm the baby down anyway, as most people do this. I think it's a lot of worry over nothing xxx
CommentAuthorbarbie86
MrsMoran: that is your opinion.
My OH and I both have very strong feelings about children, in that we really don't like them. We are childfree by choice (do not have children and will never have them), and we avoid them as much as possible. We don't find them cute, and for us, a baby crying during our vows would seriously ruin it. We wouldn't not notice, we wouldn't be like 'aww, bless', we'd be standing their trying not to grimace and feeling pretty mad. We have no desire to risk that so that a baby who has no idea what is going on can be there.
I personally think that saying that mum and baby can attend the wedding breakfast but not the ceremony could be a compromise; then it is up to her what she does. That is of course if the OP would be OK with that (we personally wouldn't and won't be relaxing our stance at all, for anyone). I see no issue at all with saying that unfortunately, the baby is not welcome for the ceremony, but more than welcome to be at the wedding breakfast.
CommentAuthormillz090
Each to their own opinion.... some people dont like kids so why would they have them at their wedding?
Finally marrying the love of my life !!
10th August 2013 - 9 years to the day we met !
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
I know that is my opinion, hence why I said 'I think'. All I meant was, you might avoid one situation by saying they can come, but land yourself in another tizz by asking her to stay outside for the entire ceremony.
And that is your opinion, which is fine. xxx
CommentAuthorbarbie86
Honestly, if someone 'got in a tizz' when I'd already relaxed my stance and agreed that they could bring their baby to the reception, because it wasn't allowed at a ceremony, they're not someone I'd care to have at my wedding in the first place.
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
I'm not saying they'd get in a tizz coz they wouldn't be allowed at the ceremony at all, I'm saying they might get in a tizz if she says to her brother's girlfriend that she can come with the baby, just stay outside for the whole thing, it wouldn't be worth her going anyway! I'm just saying a lot of people won't want to leave their new baby behind, so if you're happy for them to decide not to go, then fair enough xxx
CommentAuthorhis duck
I haven't said I want them to stay outside. The ceremony venue is very small and once seated is hard to sneak out if baby cries. The day we have panned is seperste to the reception which is held on another day. Which I don't mind baby at. The wedding ceremony has things planned in it that arnt suitable for children so young and its what we want and don't want to change it. the baby will be less than a year old. They already have children from prev relationships that are bridesmaids bit they are older and when I asked girlfriends children my brother wasn't happy id asked them. It is only the ceremony I don't want any babies at yes they may nit cry but again it may cry, it can't be Snook out as said before. I'm fine if they want to stay with baby.
Is a very lucky girl :)
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
I know you didn't say you wanted them to stay outside hun, it was suggested earlier and was replying to that. xxx is there not a way they could sit by the door? xxx Wouldn't you regret not having that new niece or nephew there to be able to have pictures with on the day? xx
CommentAuthorhis duck
No I wouldn't regret it. Id regret it more if we had baby there and it cried and also wed have to alter alot of plans, The venue is very small 2 exits one is up wooden stairs and the other would mean passing and disturbing me and groom.
We have saved and planned this so much that we don't want to change things. We only doing it once!!
Is a very lucky girl :)
CommentAuthorLinzi-jo
Personally I would have the baby there, especially if it was my new niece or nephew as I believe that when you get married you should be surrounded by those who you love and who love you, but just because I would do that doesn't mean you have to. At the end of the day it is your decision, but just work out whether or not you are prepared to get married without your brother there, as that may be the case if you decide not to invite the baby. If you are ok with that then don't have them there, but if not, I would rethink having the baby at the ceremony with you. But as I said, at the end of the day it is your choice xxx
Got together 14.02.2008
Got engaged 31.12.2010
Will become a Mrs on 30.08.2014 xxxxxx
CommentAuthorMrsMoran
Go with what's best for you then hun, if you really believe that it will disrupt your day, then just say it how you want it xxx
CommentAuthorRosyF77
It is totally your choice. I am only having children at my wedding because i have two of my own. I dont think your in the wrong one little bit x
CommentAuthorsussie
my lo was 5 months old at my friends wedding, and 15 at sil2b wedding and at both weddings i was asked to take the baby out if he started cryinng/playing up. (which i did) both brides said that they didnt even notice he was there. and he did start to cry during one of the readings so we did take him out.
CommentAuthorsussie
saying that though, if my friend said, look can i not bring the baby, i would have happily left him with his grandparents, sil2b would have been a different matter as in a different country
CommentAuthorMrs Ashman2b
having been to a friends wedding this weekend i would rather there be no children at my wedding. The couple have a little girl who is 18 months and it was kind of awkward at times because we all took turns in keeping her amused during the day which was fine i guess. But a the critical point during service whilst exchanging vows the inevtiable happened she toddles over to mum and dad (the bride and groom) asking for cuddles and to be picked up so i felt a bit sorry for them both really that they couldn't even enjoy that just the two of them and of course as the day wore on their daughter got more tired and grumpy the more of a damper it became. Maybe thats because i don't have children so i don't understand the bond you have but it just felt like the day was hard work for them and i don't think anyone should feel like that on their wedding day?
CommentAuthorVelcro
i was at an engagement party on saturday. It's made me decide i most definately do not want balloons at my wedding. I stuck my heel through a few because im a proper kill joy lol. Just to throw that out there to any other child haters like myself haha. Noticed a cousins wife was up the duff as well. I know you can't put a pregnanacy ban on peole (as much as Id love to myself lol) but that doesnt mean you should expect to have a screaming baby there if you dont want one there. I know they may not cry, but tbh, it's not a risk Id be willing to make myself. Think her kid will be one or so when its born. So she just better keep it quiet if they come
Wibbly wobbly, timey wimey
*Kelbel* is my wedding twinny!
CommentAuthoremmaaa
We're not having any children, and fortunately the time has passed now for any pregnancies to land us in this dilemma, because I'm not really sure what we'd do! I don't have a problem with children that are old enough to understand the importance of what's happening and can sit still and quietly through the ceremony, but both the weddings I went to last summer had babies crying and toddlers running around, and even though the parents were fairly proactive in trying to deal with them, there's only so much they can do. The screams of the toddler as they were picked up and taken out (by his dad, who was best man) grated on me as a guest, it would have driven me mad if it was our wedding.
I think a lot of it would depend on whether the baby would take up a guest space or not, if you'd have to not invite someone to the day to make room for a baby you don't want there anyway, that would be an impossible situation for us, we're right up to capacity as it is on our essentials, let alone the people we really want there. However, if the baby was *free* as it were, and it was a case of someone we really wanted there who had a very young child that was too young to be left, I think a compromise would have to be made, depending on the circumstances. To be honest, in your situation, the child will be... 9 months-ish? In my opinion, that would likely be old enough to be able to be left with someone else for the ceremony (half and hour / 45 mins.) At that age I'd not really have a problem with them being at the breakfast, that'll be busy enough for it not to matter if they were crying.
CommentAuthorPenguinJ
We are only having nephew as he is the ring bearer (he will be 3 at that time) and possibly my cousins 3 children. but no extras will be there.
So lucky to be marrying my soulmate on 18/07/20
CommentAuthorNevlar
i agree no babies! they are too unpredicatable!!
CommentAuthoralmost a year wife!!
We've got one little one who is our fg and I love the bones of her! But her mum (my bestie) has said she's going home later on as she wants a drink and a dance!!!!
Ill marry my hero
CommentAuthorCarolineW10
I really like this conervsation because im in the same situation....
Its my sister who is preganant (she is the maid of honour) and her husband is our Usher, i was afraid that if the baby started crying she/he would be handed to my mum and my mum out of repect for us would take the baby out- and therefore miss my wedding. Its such a difficult one and im suprised how some of my friends have reacted when i have said no children.
I dont think people should say...'why would you not invite your baby niece/nephew to your wedding day- they are family! its not about not wanting them there, its just when you save and wait for as long as some of the brides have on here you want to hear your vows and your speeches. However you could be lucky and have babies that will sleep through the whole ceremony. I have suggested a babysitter, (a qualified babysitter) to sit in the room next to us, we will of course pay for her, and all the children can play with the games etc that we will provide, but again some of my friends are dead against this. Ive suggested to people that this is what the offer is, if they come they come and we will be happy to see them if they decide not to come then its their loss!
Each to their own i suppose! I also need to add that it is literally the 20 minute service that i didnt want the children to come to, they are welcome to the meal and evening party.
CommentAuthorVelcro
A couple of my friends had a grumble about the no kids out side of family, but i said its non-negotiable lol
If they arent happy with your suggestions Caroline, then that's their problem, that's way more accomodating than I'd ever willing to be, you've attempted to work around it, if people can't appreciate that then balls to them.
Wibbly wobbly, timey wimey
*Kelbel* is my wedding twinny!
CommentAuthorNicoleee_x
Hi hun, you said you're not bothered about the reception so just sit your brother & gf down and say to them that before she got pregnant you & h2b had already decided on a no children policy for the ceremony and you're really sorry but you still want to stick to that but then say that you'd love for them to bring the bub to the reception and can't wait to have lots of pics of her when ur in ur dress. I just think you need to be really tactile about what you say, and be quite sugary sweet but being your brother he should understand and respect your wishes but I do know that some people get a bit funny when their children are involved :/ Good luck, let us know how it goes xx
CommentAuthorLauraJo87
I don't see why there is a problem really, having no babies at the ceromony, particularly if they are welcome at the reception..
It's not like your niece or nephew will be old enough to remember it or even know what's going on. Obviously if she's breast feeding, that complicates matters and I think if she chooses not to come because she doesn't want to leave baby with someone, that's her choice and is fair enough.
However, they might be glad for a day off, particularly if she has people willing to babysit for her!
We aren't having any children as we don't have any 'younger' ones in the family any more....I do know what you mean though, babies do cry and gurgle at the most inopportune times and i have seen it interrupt a few ceremonies xx
My Beating Heart Belongs To You
30 August 2013
The First Day Of My Happily Ever After
CommentAuthorJessicaE26
i agree, i said no kid's till after! someone still brought there kids and sisters and brothers along without asking and she knew me and my hubby didnt want them there, and they cried and screamed all way through which put me off and messed up all my vows in front of everyone! i was so angry! were renewing ours vows next year and the person in question is pregnant and think's she's coming, um nope not after last time lol!xx
Proud military wife ready for x2 wedding with my soilder
CommentAuthorRennie1989
The youngest child at my wedding will be five or six (if said child is coming, if not the youngest will be seven). I don't want babies there either and I'm fortunate that nobody has any young children to bring with them.
I can't see why your mum's disgusted, it's your day after all. I understand not wanting to have babies at weddings, I don't think weddings are good ceremonies for them anyway, especially if they need to sleep. I would just be sensitive about bringing up with your brother, you might find he'll agree with you, that way he'll have more time to enjoy himself without worrying about a child.
CommentAuthorMrs Jones
Im having children only at the reception and if people dont like it, tough! Its my wedding!
I used to care what people thought but i dont now as they will never be satisfied and will always find something to complain about!
Do what you think is best hun. Its you and your h2b day. Dont have regrets
Got together - 05.11.2006
Engaged - 05.11.2009
Married - 22.05.2013
CommentAuthordevilspartner
My brother-in-law did invite children but he hired a babysitter to look after the younger children in a different room while the ceremony was conducted, they later joined their parents for the reception
CommentAuthorMargaretH85
Those of you saying 'no babies' - what about babies under six months who are being exclusively breastfed - you can't expect a breastfeeding mother to leave her baby for hours on end?!
Remember not all breastfeeding mothers find it easy to express milk.
CommentAuthorsarahjo89
do you have your own children? me and H2B don't and we feel the same as you. I think the people who do have children always find it odd when the bride to be/hubby to be say they don't want children there. My H2B has 2 sisters and 2 brothers who have at least 2 children each so when we said no children, some people weren't too impressed. Its not selfish. I completely agree with you. this is your day, have it how you want :-) xx
Together: 9th June 2007
Proposed: 15th November 2010, Las Vegas
Too excited to become Mrs Flanagan 8th June 2014
CommentAuthorFee
im not having an at mine either let the parents have a night off..tell them its their turn to let their hair down and not stress ive said in a ncie way i dont want children around adults when theyve all been drinking they would get bored..good luck x